International Workshop
Workshop Program at Charterhouse Ittingen / Switzerland, November 05-06, 2010
Objectives of Health Technology Assessments (HTAs):
Public expectations, societal preferences, and current evaluation methods
Managed & Organized by the
Institute for Innovation & Valuation in Health Care, InnoValHC, Wiesbaden / Germany
Moderated by
Prof. HSG Urs Brügger, Winterthur Institute of Health Economics, Zurich University of Applied Sciences / Switzerland, and
Prof. Michael Schlander, University of Heidelberg & InnoValHC / Germany
Participants include
Representatives of the Federal authorities, Cantons, Federal parliament, patient groups, medical community, experts, health insurer and the pharmaceutical industry
Welcome and Introduction to the Project
Thomas B. Cueni, Interpharma (Switzerland) & Stefan Kaufmann, santésuisse (Switzerland)
[View Program ...]
Value Judgements in the Society
Topic: What are the objectives of collectively financed health care? Value judgements and societal preferences
Prof. Michael Schlander, Heidelberg & Wiesbaden / Germany
Objectives of Collectively Financed Health Schemes, Decision-Makers’ Needs, and Health Economic Analysis
[View Presentation ...]
Claude Longchamp, gfs.bern, Berne / Switzerland
I. Results from Swiss and international survey studies
[View Presentation ...]
Prof. Jeffrey Richardson, Monash University, Melbourne, Victoria / Australia
II. Empirical evidence from the social sciences: Why we should not minimize cost per QALY
[View Presentation ...]
International Experience
Topic: Health economic evaluation paradigms and international experience
Prof. Panos Kanavos, London School of Economics (LSE), London / England
HTA and NICE
The Role of Health Technology Assessment and the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence (NICE) in England and Wales
[View Presentation ...]
Prof. Ulf Persson, University of Lund / Sweden
The Swedish Experience (TLV)
I. Modifying the standard approach to health economic evaluation
[View Presentation ...]
PD Dr. Andreas Gerber, Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG), Cologne / Germany
The German Experience (IQWiG)
II. Modifying the standard approach to health economic evaluation
[View Presentation ...]
Prof. Gérard de Pouvourville, ESSEC Business School, Paris / France
The French Experience (HAS)
HTA based on comparative clinical evaluation: Life without cost-effectiveness?
[View Presentation ...]
Prof. Peter Ubel, Duke University, Durham, North Carolina / USA
Utility, adaptation and happiness in health economics
Preference-based (decision) or experienced utility?
[View Presentation ...]
Evaluation Methods
Topic: Critical appraisal of current evaluation methods
Prof. Amiram Gafni, McMaster University, Hamilton, Ontario / Canada
Incremental Cost Effectiveness Ratios (ICERs)
Information created to evade reality (ICER): things we should not look to for answers
[View Presentation ...]
Prof. Tom Philipson, University of Chicago, Illinois / USA
Static and dynamic efficiency
Changes of cost effectiveness over time: (How) Should We Capture the Dynamics of Innovation?
[View Presentation ...]
Prof. Jeffrey Richardson, Monash University, Melbourne, Victoria / Australia
Individual versus social preferences
How Do We Translate Individual Preferences into Social Preferences?
[View Presentation ...]
Prof. Weyma Luebbe, University of Regensburg / Germany
Measures of benefit, social values and claims
(How) Can the Current Health Economic Evaluation Paradigms Be Amended to Meet Fairness Objectives?
[View Presentation ...]